Copyright 2004 T. Sheil & A. Sheil  All Rights Reserved

Army Men Homepage


 

Rating the Troops

 

We need a standard - a baseline, of sorts, for evaluating the toy soldiers we collect.  This common language will help when describing figures, cataloguing, etc.  These charts are but a guide for developing your own system, to categorize and evaluate troops:


The left column is the category, the right foru columns are the gradations or ratings of that category: 

 

Type

 

Nationality

 

Era

 

Branch of Service

 

Specifics

 

Maker

 

Designer

 

Manufacturer

 

Nation of manufacture

 

Year of manufacture

 

Generation

 

Original

 

Recast

 

Copy

 

Clone

 

Sets (How is it sold?)

 

Bagged

 

Individual

 

Playset

 

Other (cereal prize, etc.)

 

Thickness

 

Full round

 

Semi-flat

 

Flat

 

Other

 

Color density

 

Opaque

 

Waxy

 

Translucent

 

Mixed

 

Color Sheen

 

Flat

 

Glossy

 

Semi-gloss

 

Muted

 

Base

 

Round

 

Oval

 

Rectangular

 

Other

 

Base Surface

 

Flat

 

Raised

 

Scenicked (grass, ground, etc)

 

Other

 

Base Attached

 

Molded on

 

Separate

 

Diorama

 

No base

 

Build

 

Spare

 

Average

 

Squat

 

Thick

 

Proportion - limbs

 

Lank

 

Short

 

Irregular

 

Regular

 

Proportion - head

 

Small / Slim

 

Large / Wide

 

Bulbous

 

Regular

 

Proportion - weapons & gear

 

Too small or truncated

 

Oversize

 

Normal

 

Varied off-sizes

 

Pose

 

Stiff / AStatue@

 

Fluid / Liquid

 

Normal

 

Awkward

 

Animation

 

Stiff / ARobotic@

 

Fluid / AInvertebrate@

 

Average

 

Dynamic

 

Detail

 

Blurred

 

Thick

 

Average

 

Crisp

 

Face

 

Blank

 

Offbeat

 

Normal

 

Expressive

 

The next table covers equipment and gear:

 

 

Type

 

Combat

 

Mobilized

 

Camp

 

Rear Echelon

 

Unit

 

Regular

 

Elite

 

Support

 

Irregular

 

Uniform

 

Combat

 

Dress

 

Informal

 

Other

 

Headgear

 

Cap / Hat

 

Helmet

 

Bare

 

Other

 

Footwear

 

Shoes

 

Boots

 

Sandals

 

Bare

 

Belts / web gear

 

Webbed

 

Leather

 

Cloth

 

Other

 

Backpack

 

Large

 

Small

 

None

 

 

 

Weapon

 

Missile (Gun, bow)

 

Hand-to-hand (sword, knife, etc)

 

Thrown (grenade, spear)

 

Other

 

Armor

 

Plate

 

Mail or Scale

 

None

 

Other

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

This table covers specific troop types:     

 

 

Modern

 

Rifleman

 

Light Machine-gunner (.30 cal, M60, MG34 / 42, etc.)

 

Automatic Rifle (BAR)

 

Submachine Gun (Thompson, M3, Sten, etc)

 

 

 

Bazooka / Antitank Rocket

 

Flamethrower

 

Grenade thrower

 

Mortar

 

 

 

Gun Crew

 

Minesweeper

 

Radio / Telephone

 

Officer or Observer

 

 

 

Medic

 

Heavy Machine-gunner

 

Vehicle Crewman (tank, armoered car, etc.)

 

Pilot / Airman

 

Black Powder

 

Rifleman

 

Musketeer

 

Officer

 

Grenadier

 

 

 

Artilleryman

 

Cavalry Regular

 

Cavalry Lancer / Uhlan

 

Cavalry  Hussar / Light

 

Cowboy

 

Pistol

 

Rifle

 

Shotgun

 

Lariat / Whip

 

 

 

Bandit

 

Sheriff

 

Other

 

 

 

Indian

 

Chief

 

Tomahawk

 

Spear

 

Archer

 

 

 

Mohawk

 

Mounted Archer

 

Rifle

 

Pistol

 

 

 

Mounted Spearman

 

Mounted Other

 

Medicine Man

 

 

 

Medieval 1

 

Knight / Noble

 

Soldier

 

Peasant

 

Other

 

Medieval 2 / Ancient 1

 

Full Armor

 

Half Armor

 

Unarmored

 

Other

 

Medieval 3 / Ancient 2

 

Short Weapon (axe, mace)

 

Sword

 

Pole Weapon

 

Flexible Weapon (Morningstar)

 

 

 

Bow

 

Crossbow

 

Gun

 

Thrown weapon

 

Medieval 4 / Ancient 3

 

Foot

 

Mounted

 

Crewman

 

Siege Team

 

 

 

 

Charioteer

 

Wagoneer

 

 

 

 

 

Ancient

 

Noble

 

Centurion

 

Regular Soldier

 

Irregular

 

Space / Sci Fi

 

Astronaut suited

 

Astronaut uniform

 

Ground Crew

 

Scientist

 

Sci Fi Species

 

Human

 

Alien - Bug-eyed Monster

 

Alien - AArea 51"

 

Alien - Humanoid

 

 

 

Alien - Reptilian

 

Alien - Fur Mammalian

 

Alien - Birdlike

 

Alien Other

 

Robots

 

Humanoid / Android

 

Robbie and variants

 

Old Fashioned (boxlike head and body)

 

Mechanical (tracked, wheeled or other non-pedal propulsion)

 

Sci Fi Equipment

 

Scientific / Exploration

 

Firing weapons

 

Weapons crew

 

Hand Held weapons

 

Fantasy

 

Human

 

Dwarf

 

Elven

 

Goblin / Orc

 

 

 

Dragon

 

Reptilian

 

Mammal

 

Bird

 

 

 

Elemental

 

Ghost - Spectre

 

Large Monster

 

Other

 

Ancient Japan

 

Samurai

 

Soldier

 

Peasant

 

Ninja

 


A very general guide to condition:

Condition Mint Like new Excellent Very Good Good Fair Poor
#1 The Figure No marks or blemnishes - perfect No playwear No scratches or breaks. Light  Playwear Small scratches, light playwear. minor schips Broken bayonets, scratches, moderate playwear Broken weapons, chew marks, chipping, heavy -playwear Missing weapons, limbsd, heavy chewing,
#2 Painted figures As above, plus all paint clear, not chipped or faded Paint unchipped, no flaking,  Corlors may be only slightly faded - under 10% lighter than original shade Minor chipping or fading.  up to 15% fading Some chipping, fading up to 25% of originalshade Heavy chipping, 50% of paint missing Vestiges of the original paint, haeavy fading No paint

click here to return to the main page